المدة الزمنية 2:56

Caramelldansen 2008 VS 2018 Comparison (English Version)

بواسطة v4mpirism

227 600 مشاهدة

4.9 K

تم نشره في 2018/05/25

2008 version: /watch/Imw1dAkZ76AZ1 2018 version: /watch/4RRiRcIy75xyi idk I saw someone in the comments suggest it so here's a quick vid.

الفئة

عرض المزيد

تعليقات - 1220

@

@v4mpirismمنذ 6 سنوات My personal opinion: I like the art style of the 2018 version better, but I like the fluidity of the 2008 version. I also think it looks better without being 3D. 2156
@

@crazyXninjaXfishyمنذ 6 سنوات 2008 Version just looks so much more fun. 2149
@

@fallingstars5683منذ 6 سنوات at least the 2008 one was on beat
and the limbs didn't look like boneless noodles 2032
@

@sakurablossom2949منذ 6 سنوات Let's be honest guys. 2008 Caramell Girls danced this way better 663
@

@isaacandrews6515منذ 6 سنوات Some things can never replace the original. 1317
@

@shinoxsageمنذ 6 سنوات You know, for a 10 year anniversary, you think they'd put a lot more time and money into their product than telling a 16 year old to replicate the id="hidden3" class="buttons"> video in a more anime style with half of an Adobe Flash program and some Go Animate. 2008 ftw. ....وسعت 1095
@

@raspen4648منذ 6 سنوات I'm mildly disappointed that the animation in the old version is bouncier and more fun to look at
The new one kinda looks like they're id="hidden4" class="buttons"> using the warp tool on 2d figures
I wasn't expecting Pixar but I was definitely expecting something like 2018 mmd y'know
Still happy to be reminded of a simpler time when the rainbow filter was the only acceptable filter ....وسعت 445
@

@CherrygroveCityمنذ 6 سنوات I cannot help but say 3D >2D this time, it pains me, but it’s the truth. 440
@

@magdalenelooper7522منذ 6 سنوات First they were lolis and now they are all grown 490
@

@GoodNostalgiaمنذ 6 سنوات I want to look at this without being blinded by nostalgia. In the end, I still prefer the 2008 one. The girls have more energy to their dance moves and id="hidden5" class="buttons"> there's dynamic camera movement. You can see them at more angles than just front-facing. The new girls aren't even singing in sync with the music, much less each other! Purple-haired girl is even looking around like she doesn't know what's going on! And their side-stepping move looks noodley! As for character design, both 2008 and 2018 look unsettling if you stare long enough! ....وسعت 135
@

@ghostgirl7089منذ 6 سنوات The 2018 one looks like it was badly done in Live 2d, since it looks too noodlely and not like an actual person dancing, more of a cartoon. The original id="hidden6" class="buttons"> looks more like someone actually dancing. I love the 2D of the new but the 3D is leagues and miles better than it ....وسعت 881
@

@strawberryblossom4431منذ 6 سنوات 2008 one looks like they are actually having fun 46
@

@grimsum4916منذ 6 سنوات I like the hip bounce more in the 2008 because the skirts and such bounce with the girls and there just seems like there is more energy to it, however id="hidden7" class="buttons"> the new slide dance with the arms to the side in the 2018 version is very fluid and I like that way more. I also like the updated textures/remasters of the girls, they no longer have potato faces. ....وسعت 167
@

@leokitsune4056منذ 6 سنوات Now lets see how 2028 turn out if there will be ine 63
@

@kendra9002منذ 6 سنوات The 2018 one has a really cute style, but the original seemed much more bouncy and energetic. 95
@

@ScorpionsFatalityمنذ 6 سنوات 2018 looks like it was thrown together in flash. It just looks slow and stiff. Love the 2008 one though since i remember it when it came out xD id="hidden8" class="buttons"> />2018 one is cringy. That's just me though. It looks like they're ragdolls being stretched. ....وسعت 770
@

@ellytucker3134منذ 6 سنوات I love the fact to they got rid of the spine twister move at 505
@

@Anppanمنذ 6 سنوات I like the 2018 style, more anime looking and doesn't look like a lifeless smiling doll dancing. But the 2008 one had better anatomy and more sync id="hidden9" class="buttons"> than the 2018 version. 2008 was also less brighter, made my eyes hurt less.
They repaired the girl's spine, but it had a price, the 3 needed to have their arm bones turned into rubber like in harry potter ....وسعت 38
@

@rae2cool4youمنذ 4 سنوات The fact that they took out the back breaking move makes me want to cry. that part was my favorite. 10
@

@moppyearltea3381منذ 6 سنوات 2008 still looks better for me - they look so energetic! 2018 looks like it would rather be somewhere else. 47
@

@bloodmuzzleمنذ 6 سنوات In the 2008 one you can see the girls quote "Dance to the beat." 16
@

@cloveetvمنذ 4 سنوات In the 2008 version they’re doing a lot more movement than the 2018 version. Also in the 2008 version the skirt bounces and in the 2018 it just sways. In the 2018 version it doesn’t show the word “Caramell” who were the original writers so it just looks stolen. The band Caramell actually created the song before Caramella Girls did the 2018 version. ....وسعت 12
@

@1tastiger1منذ 6 سنوات 2008 looks like it was made on older technology, 2018 (while having a better art style) looks like it was made on a very cheap budget (understandable) id="hidden11" class="buttons"> but to the point that you can almost see the skeletons used to move the bodies. 2008 is better; looks like they tried to have something fun to watch with that one. ....وسعت 22
@

@arandomviewer9567منذ 6 سنوات is it bad for me to say that i like the 2008 version of this only because its 3d and more cute? 153
@

@frillcovenantمنذ 6 سنوات the original had more weight to the animation instead of being floaty. It was also a bit more visually appealing with more bits of animation than the newer one which seems like a single gif 31
@

@nin10dogmod90منذ 6 سنوات Ten Years.
Are we old, now? 9
@

@islasfuntimechannel4414منذ 6 سنوات I like the 2008 one better
Thats it 13
@

@cheeseucakeeمنذ 2 سنوات if they mixed the art style of 2018 with the dance moves of 2008 it’d be pretty good imo 7
@

@urmomlol1557منذ 2 سنوات 2008 feels like they wouldn’t judge you while 2018 feels like they would 2
@

@gamegirl8722منذ 6 سنوات They traded the rest of their bones for a spine. 7
@

@cameoshadowness7757منذ 6 سنوات 2008 had more movement and felt way less stiff. 3
@

@neaht6169منذ 4 سنوات Song: "dance to the beat!"
2018 remake: literally misses almost every beat 2
@

@Lupiterzمنذ 6 سنوات On a technical level, 2018 would be considered best
But 2008 is done from some sort of passion, it's bouncy and so much more fun. It makes id="hidden13" class="buttons"> me grin, while the new one doesn't. That's all I need to say which one is my favourite. ....وسعت 5
@

@rimcorom9224منذ 5 سنوات 2008: this is funny!
2018: wtf? i dont want this 23 year old girl 50$ animation! 4
@

@sugarystarburstمنذ 5 سنوات Comparing the drawing/animation of them side by side. 5
@

@TfrmScمنذ 2 سنوات Caramelldansen will always hold a special place in my heart because of the nostalgia 1
@

@Mimyakkoمنذ 6 سنوات YESSSSSSSSS THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR MAKING THIS
@

@xcept1281منذ 2 سنوات Now this makes me realize how good the 2008 animation actually was, the only problem was the art style LOL 3
@

@megamilo95منذ 6 سنوات 2008 girls has more energy and the 2018 girls. I'm not saying that 2018 girls are bad. There good. But 2008 girls are just a bit better
Edit: it's my opinion. To avoid C R I T I C I S M 91
@

@spiked_cheeriosمنذ 5 سنوات They really made the audio worse/better. If you’ve heard the misheard lyrics, they updated the audio for the 2018 version to make it sound more like the actual lyrics. 1
@

@enderf0495منذ 5 سنوات I remember playing this nonstop on my 11th birthday. I was a fucking weeb 2
@

@Metallica420منذ 6 سنوات Was literally looking for this and YouTube put it in auto play lol 11
@

@siennahartle9069منذ 6 سنوات In the old version they look like they’re having way more fun 1
@

@TheRealFDRمنذ 4 سنوات 2008 makes me feel like I'm going to get arrested
2018 makes me want to get arrested 2
@

@beccaniccals952منذ 6 سنوات Oh My Wow The Trio Of Caramella Girls Has Been Growing Up Over The Years Since Their Debut Back In 2008 5
@

@chouzetfafnir7880منذ 4 سنوات Escuhe esta cancion cuando tenia 5 años con mi amigo japones
@

@halo12390العام الماضي love 2008 version. the entire stage dance to the beat with them. feels more to the rhytym. also more intense movement makes me feel good
@

@unidentifiederrorsمنذ 6 سنوات I like the style of the new one, just not how it was animated and all. It be cool if it was still 3d and maybe with the 2018 style on some newer 3d models, then idk use a program like mmd for the video+ dancing. 63
@

@Doraemon-sw1znمنذ 5 سنوات I’m not surprised to hear the word “meme” from a song from 2008. 3
@

@mellow_mikuمنذ 5 سنوات It's been 10 years and they still wear those intresting outfits.. 1
@

@f1r3hunt3rz5منذ 6 سنوات You guys are blinded by nostalgia. They made the 2018 version to suit the preference of the young'uns of this era, just like the 2008 one was made id="hidden17" class="buttons"> for us 10 years ago. They removed the spine breaking twisting part and added more moe/cute factor to their expressions. They also toned down the intensity of the moves so that they don't look impossoble or painful. But it's true the 2008 has more face emotions and moves though. Good thing they moved away from using those 3D models, it looks dated, and if they use a different looking ones then people might not recognize or accept it. Caramella Girls has been using 2D anims in their new videos for quite sometime now, and I'm okay with them following the trends of time. ....وسعت 423
@

@jeiku5041منذ 6 سنوات The new version looks okay.
When paused. 1
@

@pleasehelp2446منذ 2 سنوات When you went to highschool during this songs hayday and everyone was doing the dance at homecoming. I still remember the steps
@

@yukimikoto1808منذ 6 سنوات The thing that really bugs me, is that the dancing is asynchrone to the song in the 2018 version as it is too slow 1
@

@SynisterFourمنذ 6 سنوات I guess the girls have grown up, maybe that's why they look taller in 2018 version? 5
@

@tarynisok8790منذ 6 سنوات I think the 2008 one seems more fun, fluid and less stiff while the 2018 one seems very emotionless and stiff 2
@

@JodTheCodمنذ 6 سنوات the problem I think with the 2018 one is that the movements (especially the hips) are animated slow out then slow in, making it seem like it decelerates id="hidden18" class="buttons"> after picking up speed while the 2008 is just mostly slow outs with bounces, which gives it that snap we see every beat. simple changes on the timing, and it wouldve been better animated. ....وسعت 1
@

@ElectroBlastLuigiمنذ 6 سنوات The remastered was recommended and so this video :') 2
@

@QueenJess2k05منذ 4 سنوات Even tho 2018 was remade to the animation we use now.but 2008 still brings the homies vibing
@

@Mary-ij9osمنذ 6 سنوات I like all of 2018 except the animation. I prefer the one of 2008 because the characters look less cringy 5
@

@momokomomose-virtualyoutub6677منذ 6 سنوات I actually can't believe it's been 10 years.
@

@StrickenWithFearمنذ 6 سنوات When they do their signature dance move during the chorus in the 2008 version, it becomes incredibly dizzying with the camera jerking up and down like that.
@

@Chris-tn9bfمنذ 5 سنوات better question is why does it still exist 11 years later 1
@

@anastasiarose1430منذ 6 سنوات "The downgrade" So like do y'all know what quality 780p looks like or? 3
@

@calledtrout2309منذ 6 سنوات I like the new art style but the older one flowed way better. 1
@

@TheCorazonPawprintمنذ 5 سنوات I like the 2008 version better because, the dancing catches up with the music & beat. The 2018 one. dosen't. 3
@

@TheFloraBonBonمنذ 4 سنوات No offense to anyone who may like the 2018 one, but the movement looks so stiff and what are they doing? a sliding shuffle? 1
@

@peaches3268منذ 6 سنوات You know those creepy games on "Girlgames,com" yeah that's what the new one reminds me of and needless to say.. that's really bad. 3
@

@Raakaiمنذ 6 سنوات For those who don't wish to read all of this, my opinion is that these versions are about the same in regards to quality.
There are pros and id="hidden20" class="buttons"> cons to both sides. For 2008, the hip movements fit the beat more, as they move harsher than in the 2018 animation. They also have some parts animated better, such as the skirt and even the hair. Sure, the hair movement isn't natural, but it fits the beat and thus makes it aesthetically pleasing. The camera bobs are also more fitting to the beat, regardless of how hard it can be on some people's eyes.
For 2018, the art style is more detailed, the faces have improved the most, in my eyes. In this version, they also have attempted lip syncing, which I think is a cool feature. In the 2008 version, they basically have the same expression the whole video. In 2018, they also have more aesthetically pleasing visuals than the older one. There are more animations, and is more fluid, though some could argue that messes the video up. I somewhat agree. The recent verson also has some of the video actually RELATING to the lyrics, such as when they talk about countries. There's more variety in this version, thus making it a bit more entertaining to watch. I won't mention lyrics, as they aren't part of the art itself in my eyes. However, it can be convenient for those who want to understand what they're saying.
In conclusion, I'd say they're equivalent in quality, though in different ways. ....وسعت 2
@

@sanaa3576منذ 6 سنوات This was my introduction to anime 10 YEARS AGO
@

@RaineGamer068منذ 6 سنوات Old one is better with style and motion and design in my opinion, new one looks way too. flashy 5
@

@bleepblop488منذ 6 سنوات When they do the step to the side thing in the 2018 ver it looks so weird and awkward
Edit: they look boneless 3
@

@Retrodude1985منذ 6 سنوات Happy 10th anniversary Carmelldansen!!!
@

@nyaticat6391منذ 6 سنوات How do you get worse after 10 years!? The hip movements from the 2018 version are so choppy it looks like they dislocate from the crappy flash character model. 1
@

@jerenasmr1592منذ 6 سنوات I love the 2008 version when it comes with the movements, but I love the art style more on 2018 version.
@

@LightningStarمنذ 6 سنوات I DID THE EXACT SAME THING ON MY CHANNEL LOL 5
@

@declanisduckyمنذ 6 سنوات That's why you never try to replace classics
@

@ShionAkasukiمنذ 4 سنوات I'm nearly 20 and i use to dance infront of the TV to this when I was 7
@

@zeph0shadeمنذ 6 سنوات What stopped them in 2018 from making the dance match the beat of the song..? 1